Round Details
March 9, 2026 at 12:00 AM UTC
Scenario: Dental Extraction - Post-Op Care
Robert Williams, a 58-year-old male, had surgical extraction of impacted lower right wisdom tooth (#32) two days ago due to recurrent pericoronitis. He was prescribed Amoxicillin 500mg three times daily for 7 days to prevent infection, and Ibuprofen 600mg every 6 hours as needed for pain. He reports moderate swelling on the right side of his jaw and pain level of 5/10, improving from yesterday. No signs of dry socket or infection. He is allergic to Penicillin, so was given Clindamycin 300mg three times daily instead of Amoxicillin. Follow-up appointment scheduled in 5 days for suture removal.
How did the LLMs do?
Same LLM Tests
Reconstructed text
Robert Williams is a 58-year-old male with a confirmed active allergy to Penicillin (criticality unable to assess).
Mr. Williams presented with recurrent pericoronitis of the lower right wisdom tooth (#32), associated with an impacted lower right third molar. On January 17, 2025, he underwent successful surgical extraction of the impacted lower right wisdom tooth (#32). The procedure was performed to address both the recurrent pericoronitis and the tooth impaction. The pericoronitis has since resolved.
Due to his documented Penicillin allergy, Clindamycin 300 mg oral capsule was prescribed in place of Amoxicillin, to be taken three times daily by mouth for 7 days. For post-surgical pain management, Ibuprofen 600 mg oral tablet was also prescribed, to be taken every 6 hours as needed for pain.
At his 2-day post-operative assessment on January 19, 2025, Mr. Williams reported a pain severity of 5 out of 10 on the verbal numeric rating scale, noting improvement from the prior day. Physical examination revealed moderate swelling on the right side of the jaw. Importantly, there were no signs of dry socket or infection at that time.
A follow-up appointment is booked for January 24, 2025, from 9:00 AM to 9:30 AM for suture removal following the surgical extraction.
Comparison11 issues
Missing information:
- amoxicillin 500mg dosage detail not included in the reconstruction only referenced generically as in place of amoxicillin
- the original states the planned amoxicillin regimen was 500 mg three times daily for 7 days the reconstruction does not include that original dosefrequencyduration and only notes that clindamycin was prescribed instead
- the original states the antibiotic was intended to prevent infection this indication is omitted
- amoxicillin 500mg dosage from the initially considered prescription
Hallucinated:
- statement that pericoronitis has since resolved is fabricated not stated in original
- surgery date of january 17 2025 fabricated no date in original
- followup appointment time of 900 am to 930 am fabricated no time in original
- penicillin allergy criticality described as unable to assess is fabricated not in original
- specific dates were added that are not in the original extraction on january 17 2025 postop assessment on january 19 2025 and followup on january 24 2025
- a specific followup appointment time of 900 am to 930 am was added the original only says followup is scheduled in 5 days
- allergy metadata was added that is not in the original confirmed active allergy and criticality unable to assess
Reconstructed text
Robert Williams is a male patient born in 1968. He has an active, confirmed high-criticality medication allergy to penicillin.
On 2026-03-07, he was documented to have resolved, confirmed impacted teeth, specifically an impacted lower right wisdom tooth (#32), as well as resolved, confirmed recurrent pericoronitis. On the same date, he underwent a completed surgical extraction of the impacted lower right wisdom tooth (#32) at tooth #32, identified as the lower right third molar. The procedure was performed for the impacted tooth and recurrent pericoronitis. Follow-up instructions were for suture removal in 5 days. A postoperative note states that his postoperative course was improving, with no signs of dry socket or infection.
Medication orders from 2026-03-07 include an amoxicillin 500 mg oral capsule order for post-extraction infection prophylaxis, prescribed as 500 mg by mouth three times daily for 7 days; however, this order was cancelled due to his penicillin allergy, and the note indicates that clindamycin was prescribed instead. He has an active order for clindamycin 300 mg oral capsule, prescribed as 300 mg by mouth three times daily for 7 days for post-extraction infection prophylaxis. He also has an active order for ibuprofen 600 mg oral tablet, prescribed as 600 mg by mouth every 6 hours as needed for postoperative dental pain.
Postoperative observations from 2026-03-09 show a pain level of 5/10, with pain improving from the previous day. He also had moderate postoperative swelling on the right side of the jaw, which was improving from the previous day. Assessment of the post-extraction site showed no signs of dry socket or infection.
A follow-up appointment is booked for 2026-03-14 from 09:00 to 09:30 UTC for postoperative dental follow-up and suture removal, and the patient has accepted the appointment.
Comparison12 issues
Hallucinated:
- swelling described as improving from the previous day original only states pain was improving from yesterday not the swelling
- specific dates 20260307 for procedure 20260309 for observations 20260314 for followup are fabricated
- followup appointment time of 09000930 utc is fabricated
- birth year 1968 fabricated original only states age 58
- conditions impacted teeth and pericoronitis described as resolved original does not state they are resolved patient is still in active postoperative recovery
- dosage forms oral capsule for amoxicillin and clindamycin oral tablet for ibuprofen are fabricated not specified in original
- birth year 1968 was added the original only states that he is 58 years old and does not provide a birth year
- specific calendar dates were fabricated for the extraction postoperative assessment and followup 20260307 20260309 20260314 the original gives only relative timing two days ago and followup in 5 days
- a specific followup appointment time 0900 to 0930 utc was added the original does not provide a time
- patient birth year 1968 added
- penicillin allergy specified as highcriticality
- followup appointment status patient has accepted the appointment added
Reconstructed text
Robert Williams, a male born in 1966, has an active allergy to penicillin. He was diagnosed with active pericoronitis, which was treated with the surgical extraction of his lower right wisdom tooth (Tooth 32). Clinical observations noted moderate swelling on the right side of his jaw and a reported pain severity score of 5 out of 10. To prevent infection, he was prescribed clindamycin 300 mg oral capsules, to be taken as 300 mg three times daily for 7 days. Additionally, he was prescribed ibuprofen 600 mg oral tablets, to be taken every 6 hours as needed for pain. A follow-up appointment is currently booked for the removal of his sutures.
Comparison19 issues
Missing information:
- wisdom tooth was described as impacted
- pain was reported as improving from yesterday
- surgery was performed two days ago
- pericoronitis was described as recurrent not just active
- no signs of dry socket or infection noted
- followup appointment specifically scheduled in 5 days
- initial amoxicillin 500mg prescription that was then replaced due to allergy
- extraction timing was omitted the tooth was removed two days ago
- the original states the indication was recurrent pericoronitis recurrent is omitted
- the original notes there were no signs of dry socket or infection
- the original notes amoxicillin 500 mg three times daily for 7 days was initially prescribed before being changed because of penicillin allergy
Hallucinated:
- birth year 1966 fabricated original states age 58 with no birth year specified
- pericoronitis described as active instead of recurrent as in the original
- clindamycin formulation specified as oral capsules not stated in original
- age detail changed from 58yearold to born in 1966
- pericoronitis status changed from recurrent pericoronitis to active pericoronitis
- clindamycin was given a 7day duration in the reconstruction but the original does not explicitly state a duration for clindamycin
- birth year of 1966 added original only stated 58yearold
- specific dosage forms oral capsules for clindamycin and oral tablets for ibuprofen added
Reconstructed text
Clinical Narrative for Robert Williams
Patient Demographics: Robert Williams is a 58-year-old male (DOB: May 15, 1966) with a confirmed high-risk allergy to penicillin, which causes allergic reactions. His medical record is associated with SSN 123-45-6789.
Chief Complaint & Diagnosis: Mr. Williams presented on May 15, 2024, with recurrent pericoronitis affecting his lower right wisdom tooth (#32), which had been an ongoing issue since at least May 1, 2024. This condition was confirmed as an active problem and served as the primary reason for his ambulatory dental encounter.
Procedure Performed: On May 15, 2024, between 09:30–10:15 AM, Mr. Williams underwent a surgical extraction of his impacted lower right wisdom tooth (#32) due to recurrent pericoronitis. The procedure was performed in the mandibular tooth region, and sutures were placed post-extraction.
Post-Procedure Status (May 17, 2024):
- Pain level: 5/10 (improving from prior assessment).
- Swelling: Moderate swelling on the right side of the jaw was noted, with no signs of infection.
Medications Prescribed:
- Ibuprofen 600mg oral tablet – Prescribed for pain relief, to be taken every 6 hours as needed from May 15–22, 2024.
- Clindamycin 300mg oral capsule – Prescribed three times daily for 7 days (May 15–22, 2024) as an antibiotic prophylaxis. Note: Amoxicillin was avoided due to the patient’s penicillin allergy, and substitution was not permitted.
Follow-Up Care: A follow-up appointment has been scheduled for May 20, 2024, at 10:00–10:30 AM for suture removal and a post-operative dental check. The patient has accepted this appointment.
Summary: Robert Williams, a 58-year-old male with a penicillin allergy, underwent surgical extraction of an impacted wisdom tooth (#32) on May 15, 2024, due to recurrent pericoronitis. Post-operatively, he was prescribed ibuprofen for pain and clindamycin (due to allergy constraints). His recovery is being monitored, with moderate swelling and improving pain (5/10) noted on May 17. A follow-up for suture removal is scheduled for May 20, 2024.
Comparison21 issues
Missing information:
- no signs of dry socket
- no signs of dry socket noted in original but absent from reconstruction
- original specified amoxicillin 500mg was initially prescribed before being replaced due to allergy reconstruction only mentions it was avoided
Hallucinated:
- date of birth may 15 1966 fabricated not in original
- recurrent pericoronitis described as ongoing since at least may 1 2024
- ssn 123456789 fabricated not in original
- penicillin allergy characterized as highrisk not specified in original
- followup appointment date of may 20 2024 is inconsistent original states followup in 5 days from the 2day postop visit which would be may 22 not may 20
- followup appointment time of 10001030 am fabricated not in original
- ssn 123456789 added
- penicillin allergy was labeled as highrisk and described as causing allergic reactions the original only states a penicillin allergy
- specific encounterprocedure dates added presentation and extraction on may 15 2024 postprocedure status on may 17 2024 which were not provided in the original
- procedure time added as 09301015 am
- statement that substitution was not permitted regarding amoxicillinclindamycin was fabricated
- specific medication date ranges added for ibuprofen and clindamycin may 1522 2024
- followup was changed from scheduled in 5 days to a specific appointment on may 20 2024 at 10001030 am
- statement that the patient accepted the followup appointment was added
- social security number 123456789 added
- specific calendar dates added may 1 may 15 may 17 may 20 may 22 2024
- specific times added 09301015 am for the procedure 10001030 am for the followup
- note stating substitution was not permitted for clindamycin added
Cross LLM Tests
Reconstructed text
Clinical Narrative for Robert Williams
Robert Williams is a 59-year-old male with a confirmed penicillin allergy. He presented with recurrent pericoronitis, which has since resolved, following surgical intervention. The patient underwent a completed surgical extraction of the permanent lower right third molar tooth (Tooth #32) due to complications from pericoronitis.
Post-procedure, Mr. Williams exhibits moderate swelling on the right side of the jaw and reports a pain severity score of 5/10 on a verbal numeric rating scale. For management, he has been prescribed:
- Clindamycin 300mg oral capsules, three times daily for 7 days (for infection prevention).
- Ibuprofen 600mg oral tablets, every 6 hours as needed for pain control.
A follow-up appointment is booked for suture removal. The patient has accepted this appointment.
Comparison11 issues
Missing information:
- procedure was performed two days ago
- pain is improving from yesterday
- no signs of dry socket or infection noted
- followup appointment is scheduled specifically in 5 days
- original initial prescription of amoxicillin 500mg three times daily for 7 days before correction due to allergy
- the lower right wisdom tooth 32 was impacted
- no signs of infection
Hallucinated:
- age changed from 58 to 59
- pericoronitis described as resolved not explicitly stated in the original
- the patient has accepted this appointment fabricated detail not in the original
- stated that pericoronitis has resolved
Reconstructed text
Robert Williams is a male patient born in 1968 with a confirmed active allergy to penicillin. On March 7, 2026, he underwent a surgical extraction of an impacted lower right wisdom tooth (#32) to treat recurrent pericoronitis. Both the impaction and pericoronitis are now considered resolved.
During a postoperative evaluation on March 9, 2026, Mr. Williams reported a right jaw pain severity score of 5/10, and an examination revealed moderate swelling on the right side of his jaw. Both the pain and swelling were noted to be improving compared to the previous day. A complication assessment confirmed that his postoperative course is improving with no signs of a dry socket or infection.
For postoperative management, he was prescribed clindamycin 300 mg by mouth three times daily for 7 days for infection prophylaxis—specifically chosen instead of amoxicillin due to his penicillin allergy. He was also prescribed ibuprofen 600 mg by mouth every 6 hours as needed for postoperative pain. A follow-up appointment for suture removal has been scheduled and booked for March 14, 2026, from 9:00 AM to 9:30 AM.
Comparison11 issues
Missing information:
- original mentions initial prescription of amoxicillin 500mg three times daily for 7 days before being replaced due to allergy
- the originally intended amoxicillin regimen is not fully preserved amoxicillin 500 mg three times daily for 7 days to prevent infection
Hallucinated:
- statement that impaction and pericoronitis are now considered resolved is fabricated not stated in original
- birth year 1968 fabricated original only states age 58
- followup appointment time of 900 am to 930 am fabricated
- specific surgery date of march 7 2026 fabricated
- specific calendar dates were added for the extraction and postoperative evaluation march 7 2026 and march 9 2026 the original only states the extraction was two days ago
- the followup appointment was given an exact date and time march 14 2026 900 am to 930 am the original only says it is scheduled in 5 days for suture removal
- improvement in swelling was added the original only says the pain was improving from yesterday not the swelling
- birth year 1968 added
- specific dates added march 7 2026 for surgery march 9 2026 for evaluation march 14 2026 for followup
Reconstructed text
Robert Williams is a male patient born in 1967. He has an active, confirmed high-criticality medication allergy to penicillin. His dental history includes a confirmed, resolved encounter diagnosis of recurrent pericoronitis of the lower right third molar, documented as the lower right wisdom tooth (#32), and a confirmed active diagnosis of an impacted lower right wisdom tooth (#32). On 2025-01-20, he underwent a completed surgical procedure consisting of surgical extraction of the impacted lower right wisdom tooth (#32) (CPT D7240, removal of impacted tooth - completely bony). The procedure was performed for recurrent pericoronitis and the impacted tooth, and the outcome was documented as successful.
Following the extraction, active medication orders were written on 2025-01-20. He was prescribed clindamycin 300 mg oral capsules, 300 mg by mouth three times daily for 7 days, with a total quantity of 21 capsules, no refills, and an expected 7-day supply. This was prescribed instead of amoxicillin due to his penicillin allergy, for infection prevention after the surgical extraction. He was also prescribed ibuprofen 600 mg orally every 6 hours as needed for pain. At a post-operative ambulatory follow-up encounter on 2025-01-22, documented as a Day 2 follow-up visit and still in progress, his reported pain severity score was 5/10, described as moderate pain and improving from the previous day. Examination findings noted moderate swelling of the right side of the jaw. Dry socket assessment was negative, with no signs of dry socket or infection. A follow-up appointment is booked for 2025-01-27 from 09:00 to 09:30 UTC for suture removal after the surgical extraction, and the patient has accepted the appointment.
Comparison20 issues
Missing information:
- original amoxicillin 500mg prescription details that were initially considered before being changed to clindamycin
- original states amoxicillin 500 mg three times daily for 7 days was prescribed initially before being changed due to penicillin allergy the reconstruction omits this initial amoxicillin prescription detail
Hallucinated:
- birth year 1967 fabricated original only states age 58
- cpt code d7240 and completely bony impaction classification fabricated not in original
- procedure outcome described as successful not stated in original
- specific dates 20250120 surgery 20250122 followup 20250127 suture removal fabricated original only states two days ago and in 5 days
- clindamycin formulation specified as oral capsules with total quantity of 21 capsules and no refills not in original
- followup appointment time of 0900 to 0930 utc fabricated not in original
- followup encounter described as still in progress not in original
- penicillin allergy described as highcriticality severity not specified in original
- patient acceptance of the appointment fabricated not in original
- penicillin allergy was labeled as active confirmed highcriticality the original states only that he is allergic to penicillin
- procedure codingdetail cpt d7240 removal of impacted tooth completely bony was added the original only says surgical extraction of impacted tooth 32
- clindamycin dispensingorder details were added quantity 21 capsules no refills expected 7day supply these details are not in the original
- exact appointment time 0900 to 0930 utc and that the patient accepted the appointment were added the original only says followup is scheduled in 5 days for suture removal
- birth year 1967 added
- allergy criticality level highcriticality added
- procedure date 20250120 added
- followup encounter date 20250122 added
- diagnosis status modifiers such as resolved and active added
Reconstructed text
Robert Williams is a 58-year-old male (date of birth: May 15, 1966) with a confirmed high-criticality medication allergy to Penicillin V, which manifests as an allergic reaction.
Mr. Williams presented for an ambulatory encounter on May 10, 2024, from 9:00 AM to 10:30 AM, for the evaluation and management of recurrent pericoronitis. The recurrent pericoronitis, affecting the lower right wisdom tooth (#32), had an onset date of May 1, 2024, and is confirmed and active on his problem list.
During this encounter, a surgical extraction of the impacted lower right wisdom tooth (#32) was performed between 9:30 AM and 10:15 AM. The procedure was completed successfully, with the indication being the recurrent pericoronitis.
Following the procedure, Mr. Williams developed moderate postoperative swelling on the right side of the jaw, noted as onset May 10, 2024, and documented as improving. A pain severity assessment on May 12, 2024, recorded a pain level of 5 out of 10, also noted to be improving from the prior day.
Two active medications were ordered by Dr. Smith on May 10, 2024:
- Clindamycin 300 mg — 300 mg three times daily for 7 days (notably prescribed in lieu of penicillin-based antibiotics given the patient's documented penicillin allergy).
- Ibuprofen 600 mg — 600 mg every 6 hours as needed for pain.
A follow-up appointment for suture removal has been booked for May 15, 2024, from 10:00 AM to 10:30 AM. Both the patient and the practitioner have accepted the appointment.
Comparison20 issues
Missing information:
- no signs of dry socket or infection noted at current assessment
- initial prescription of amoxicillin 500mg three times daily for 7 days was mentioned before being changed to clindamycin due to penicillin allergy
Hallucinated:
- date of birth may 15 1966 fabricated not in original
- encounter date of may 10 2024 with specific times 900 am to 1030 am fabricated
- pericoronitis onset date of may 1 2024 fabricated
- procedure times 930 am to 1015 am fabricated
- penicillin allergy specified as penicillin v original states penicillin without specifying the form
- allergy described as highcriticality not stated in original
- dr smith as the ordering physician fabricated no physician named in original
- date of birth may 15 1966 was added the original only states that the patient is 58 years old
- the allergy was changedspecifically documented as penicillin v with highcriticality severity and a described manifestation the original only states a penicillin allergy
- exact encounter datetime may 10 2024 900 am to 1030 am was added the original only says the extraction was two days ago
- exact procedure time 930 am to 1015 am was added not stated in the original
- pericoronitis onset date may 1 2024 and active on his problem list status were added not in the original
- prescribingordering clinician dr smith was added not in the original
- exact followup appointment datetime may 15 2024 1000 am to 1030 am and the statement that both patient and practitioner accepted the appointment were added the original only states followup is scheduled in 5 days
- allergy specified as highcriticality to penicillin v
- provider name dr smith added
- followup appointment specific date and time may 15 2024 1000 am to 1030 am added
- appointment acceptance status by patient and practitioner added